Welcome back to The Quick Pitch! We are officially over 50 games into the baseball season, and looking at the standings through Memorial Day, the preseason predictions are already getting flipped on their heads. We’ve noticed a couple of big surprises that the so-called experts completely missed: first, you don’t need a mega-payroll to play winning baseball, and second, “rebuilding years” don’t mean a thing if the players in the clubhouse refuse to lose.
Here are our picks for the early-season shockers, plus our weekly Texas vs. Chicago check-in!
👉 The Curveball!
You’ve got to love this time of year—when the preseason paper projections start crumbling against actual, gritty baseball.
Leesl’s Pick: Tampa Bay Rays
I have to go with the Tampa Bay Rays. After spending last season playing in the Yankees’ spring training facility due to severe hurricane damage to Tropicana Field, they are finally back under the dome—and they’ve celebrated by putting up the second-best record in all of baseball through Memorial Day.
This is a completely balanced team. The pitching staff ranks 5th in MLB in ERA, anchored beautifully by Nick Martinez and Shane McClanahan. But they aren’t just pitching; they also carry the second-highest batting average in the majors, sparked by the red-hot bats of Junior Caminero and Yandy Díaz. The preseason “experts” picked them to finish dead last in the AL East, but this roster has the depth and raw talent to stay in contention all year long.
Andy’s Pick: St. Louis Cardinals
I do love what the Rays are doing, but my pick has to be the St. Louis Cardinals. On paper, this was supposed to be a massive rebuilding year for the Redbirds. The only problem? Nobody bothered to tell the players.
They don’t have a lineup flashing massive, big-name superstars, yet they play hard and compete every single game. Rookie JJ Wetherholt looks like the real deal, hitting a crisp .297 with an incredibly mature approach in every single plate appearance. Meanwhile, Jordan Walker is finally blossoming into the player everyone hoped he’d be, racking up an impressive 114 total bases in just his first 51 games. The starting pitching hasn’t been elite, but it’s been steady enough to keep them within striking distance night after night. Best of all? As of May 26th, they sit a full game ahead of the Cubs!
👉 The Weekly Wrap: Texas vs. Chicago!
Leesl’s Texas Rangers (24-29):
The Frustration: This is an incredibly tough team to watch right now. When they pitch well, they can’t hit—and when they hit, the normally good pitching completely falls apart.
The Road Trip Reality: They just finished a painful stretch against three of the worst teams in baseball and limped away going a dismal 3-6. That includes leaving the bases loaded multiple times and getting swept by the last-place Angels on a brutal 9th-inning throwing error.
The Glaring Issue: Situational hitting. They are getting runners into scoring position but freezing up when it’s time to manufacture and create runs.
The Silver Lining: The positive about the AL West right now is that nobody is running away with it. The Rangers are sitting right in the thick of the division race—only 1.5 games out of first place behind the Athletics.
Andy’s Chicago White Sox (27-26):
The Fun Factor: The White Sox are not frustrating this year! They are actually incredibly fun to watch, which feels like a beautiful rarity for this franchise and gives South Side fans a massive reason to smile!
The Offensive Spark: A young, hungry offense is the true key to this start. Leads are built by guys like Munetaka Murakami, Colson Montgomery, and Miguel Vargas grinding out plate appearances, getting on base any way they can, manufacturing runs, and playing great situational baseball.
The Dynamic Duos: While the starting rotation has been shaky overall, Davis Martin and Anthony Kay have been absolute rocks, combining for a stellar 11-2 record.
The Back End: The bullpen has been locked down with five different pitchers consistently holding leads, capped off by Seranthony Domínguez ruthlessly collecting 11 saves. A long way to go, but a very nice start for my Sox!
👉 Swing for the Fences: Players of the Week!
Another week, another set of incredible performances in MLB. Our picks for two stars who absolutely owned the diamond over the last seven days.
- Leesl’s Pick: Yandy Díaz (DH, Tampa Bay Rays) I’m doubling down on my Rays and sticking with Yandy Díaz. As the team’s primary designated hitter, he has one job: go out there and hit. And boy, is he delivering. Through 48 games, he’s collected 58 hits, 93 total bases, and is rocking a stellar .314 batting average. He’s a massive reason why Tampa Bay holds the best record in the American League. They prove you don’t need a top three payroll to compete with the giants.
- Andy’s Pick: Otto Lopez (IF, Miami Marlins) I’m staying in the Sunshine State but going a bit off the board here to shine a light on Otto Lopez. Playing for a Marlins squad that deals with the lowest payroll and a quiet home crowd, Lopez is quietly putting on a clinic. He’s currently leading all of Major League Baseball with a spectacular .332 batting average, accumulating 100 total bases in 54 games. He’s the latest in a long tradition of gritty Marlins players who don’t make the mega-millions of the sports’ biggest stars, but show up every single night to do the dirty work and help their team win.
Step Up to the Plate! 🏟️
We want to know:
- Leesl: We’ve given you our hot takes on who is crushing it and who is keeping us on the edge of our seats.
- Andy: Are the Rays and White Sox actually built for October, or are we watching a spectacular May mirage?
Our MLB Hype Meter
Team
Tampa Bay Rays
Chicago White Sox
St. Louis Cardinals
Texas Rangers
Hype
85
70
65
45
The Verdict
🔒 Certified Contender (October Bound!)
🍿 Wildcard Chaos (Fun Summer Ahead)
🎭 Steady Spoilsports (.500 Ball)
📉 Title Defense Disaster!
Drop a comment below: What does your Hype Meter look like? Are Andy’s White Sox bound for glory, or is Leesl’s Rangers squad about to wake up and storm the wide-open AL West? Let us know your prediction ballots! 👇👇
Leave a Reply